"Once again, a major storm has stripped away the
pretense and revealed the brutal reality of American
society, exposing pervasive poverty, staggering
levels of inequality, and rampant official neglect and
corruption."
pretense and revealed the brutal reality of American
society, exposing pervasive poverty, staggering
levels of inequality, and rampant official neglect and
corruption."
"Like Katrina, Hurricane Harvey has lifted the lid on the ugly reality of American society, exposing colossal levels of social inequality, pervasive poverty and ruling class
criminality."
Capitalism and the Houston flood catastrophe
28 August 2017
Nearly twelve years to the day after Hurricane Katrina devastated the city of New Orleans, Hurricane Harvey is wreaking havoc along the Texas Gulf Coast. Harvey has caused widespread flooding in Houston, the fourth largest city in the country, with 2.3 million people and a metropolitan area population of nearly 6.5 million.
Once again, a major storm has stripped away the
pretense and revealed the brutal reality of American
society, exposing pervasive poverty, staggering levels
of inequality, and rampant official neglect and
corruption.
Scenes are unfolding of entire families trudging through waist-high water befouled with oil, sewage and chemicals; people young and old scrambling onto roofs in the desperate hope of being rescued from rapidly rising water; entire sections of the city cut off from shelter, food and clean water. The situation will only grow worse as the storm continues to drop record volumes of rain on the city and its environs.
pretense and revealed the brutal reality of American
society, exposing pervasive poverty, staggering levels
of inequality, and rampant official neglect and
corruption.
Scenes are unfolding of entire families trudging through waist-high water befouled with oil, sewage and chemicals; people young and old scrambling onto roofs in the desperate hope of being rescued from rapidly rising water; entire sections of the city cut off from shelter, food and clean water. The situation will only grow worse as the storm continues to drop record volumes of rain on the city and its environs.
In the richest country in the world, where
trillions of dollars were made available to the
banks in the aftermath of the 2008 financial
crash, widespread destruction and loss of life
have become a common feature of the
tornadoes, floods, hurricanes and other
severe weather events that occur with
increasing frequency. This is above all due to the decay of infrastructure and an acute social crisis that has left millions without the means to prepare for a natural disaster.
The victims, as always, are overwhelmingly working-class. Once again, scenes of human suffering amid official dysfunction are shattering the claims of the United States to be a land of prosperity and progress.
As in every such crisis, the spontaneous response of ordinary people is one of social solidarity. Victims of the storm are rushing to help their neighbors and thousands of people are pouring into the impacted area to assist in saving lives and providing food, shelter and medical care. This stands in the starkest contrast to the authorities, who did nothing to ward off the impact of a major flood or prepare to deal with its consequences.
This is despite the fact that Houston and southeast Texas have seen one flood disaster after another. The very existence of Houston as a major port city is due to the hurricane in 1900 that destroyed the nearby city of Galveston. Since the turn of the new century, Houston has been hit by tropical storm Allison in 2001, Hurricane Rita in 2005 and Hurricane Ike in 2008. Harvey is the third major flooding event in Houston in the past three years. Over the past forty years, Houston has had more floods than any other major city in the United States. Floods are the number one cause of deaths from natural events in Houston, known as the “bayou city.”
A center of the oil industry and home to the Bush family, Houston and the state of Texas are held up as models of unrestrained free market capitalism. Houston and other major Texas cities have seen substantial growth as major corporations relocated to take advantage of the state’s low corporate tax rates, minimal regulations and low-wage workforce, which includes millions of undocumented immigrants.
For decades, the city has allowed developers and real estate speculators to carry out uncontrolled expansion, replacing wetlands and prairie lands, which absorb water, with paved surfaces, increasing the flood risk to the city. National, state and local politicians have ignored the repeated warnings of scientists and experts that they were courting disaster.
Hurricane protection infrastructure has been neglected. After Hurricane Ike, experts proposed the construction of seawalls along the coast and the erection of a floodgate around the Houston Ship Channel. This project has yet to materialize. Its cost is estimated at $6 billion to $8 billion, a small fraction of the revenue of the US oil industry in a single year.
While the hurricane and flood may be acts of nature, the scale of their impact has been magnified by man-made factors. Indeed, even the weather events are profoundly affected by economic and social conditions. There is no question that global warming, the result of the anarchic, irrational and profit-driven nature of capitalism, is responsible for the increasing frequency and severity of storms and floods in the US and around the world.
As far as the American ruling class is concerned, the main assets to be protected are the oil refineries in the Houston area, not the city’s working-class residents. Appearing on the “Fox News Sunday” program, Secretary of State and multimillionaire former ExxonMobil CEO Rex Tillerson offered reassurances to the financial elite that its investments were safe, declaring that the oil and gas industry was “probably among the most prepared for these types of events.”
The Wall Street Journal published an article on Sunday, as the floodwaters were rising in Houston, bearing the headline “Hurricane Harvey Unlikely to Damage Insurers’ Balance Sheets.”
Houston exemplifies the colossal levels of social inequality in America. Thirteen of the world’s roughly 1,600 billionaires live in the city, which has an official poverty rate of 25 percent and a child poverty rate of 38 percent. A recent study by the Pew Research Center found that Houston is the most economically segregated city in the United States, with the rich geographically isolated from the poor.
Many who were stranded by Harvey’s
floodwaters have told reporters that
they simply lacked the money to
evacuate.
As after Hurricane Katrina, the BP oil spill of 2010 and dozens of floods in Houston and across the country, nothing will be done to make the victims of the disaster whole. More than a decade after Hurricane Katrina, tens of thousands of former residents have still not been able to return home, and whole neighborhoods in New Orleans remain depopulated wastelands. Moreover, the events in Houston come as the Trump administration proposes to carry out hundreds of millions of dollars in cuts to FEMA in the fiscal year 2018 budget, including sharp reductions to projects associated with the Federal Flood Insurance Program.
The spontaneous demonstration of solidarity, compassion and energy on the part of working people in response to the Houston flood disaster shows in embryo the immense potential for the development of a truly humane and rational society that serves the needs of the people. What stands in the way are the outmoded social relations of capitalism, which enable a tiny elite to monopolize wealth and resources and plunder society to amass ever greater personal fortunes.
What is required is the mobilization of the working class to put an end to the capitalist system and to establish socialism, based on common ownership and control of the productive forces and the principle of social equality.
Tom Hall
The Houston flood disaster: A social crime of the American oligarchy
29 August 2017
The world is looking on in shock as Houston, Texas, the fourth-largest city in the United States, is engulfed by flood waters. At least nine people are dead, a figure that will no doubt rise in the coming days. Thousands remain stranded, awaiting rescue. Tens of thousands have been forced to take shelter in emergency accommodations. Some of the worst rain is yet to come.
The catastrophic flooding engulfing Houston and southeast Texas is spreading to cities as far away as Dallas and Austin and threatening to once again overwhelm New Orleans, Louisiana. Hurried evacuations are being organized in cities throughout the region, as well as previously unaffected neighborhoods in Houston, where residents are being forced to abandon their homes as officials release water from overwhelmed and endangered reservoirs.
Twelve years after Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans, an even larger and more populous metropolitan area is being turned into a scene of indescribable suffering. The countless examples of human solidarity among the victims, overwhelmingly working class and of all races, contrasts starkly with the indifference and incompetence of the government and political establishment.
Like Katrina, Hurricane Harvey has lifted the
lid on the ugly reality of American society,
exposing colossal levels of social inequality,
pervasive poverty and ruling class criminality.
Behind the mindless media commentary, generally favorable to the White House and the right-wing Republican governor of Texas, and the pro-forma statements of politicians, one senses nervousness and fear that this latest demonstration of the failure of American capitalism will trigger an eruption of social indignation.
But the authorities cannot conceal their complacency and indifference. In a disgusting performance, President Donald Trump gave a press conference Monday in which he combined lavish praise for the official response to the flood disaster, calling it “incredible to watch” and a display of “cooperation and love,” with bathos about “one American family” that “hurts together and endures together.”
Reciting his scripted remarks as though he were reading the phonebook, Trump offered no proposals to relieve the suffering of the victims or provide them with money to rebuild their lives. He evaded a question about his proposal to slash hundreds of millions of dollars from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), including steep cuts to the Federal Flood Insurance Program.
FEMA administrator William “Brock” Long on Monday gave himself and the government a blanket amnesty for their dereliction, declaring, “You could not forecast this up. You could not dream this forecast up.”
The Wall Street Journal sounded the same theme in an editorial posted Monday. “Immunity from nature’s fury,” the newspaper wrote, “is an illusion that humans cultivate until we are forced to confront that fury again. We forget the damage that storms and earthquakes can do.”
This renunciation of any responsibility for the
unfolding disaster in Houston was combined
with praise for the massive accumulation of
wealth among the uppermost layers of
society, declaring that “Complex societies can
better cope with the damage if they have a
reservoir of accumulated wealth” among
“private sources.”
Thus, according to the leading mouthpiece of Wall Street, the answer to the unfolding tragedy in Texas is the further enrichment of the financial oligarchy!
Such claims that catastrophic events like the Texas flood are inevitable “natural disasters,” and nothing can be done either to forestall, contain or manage them, are self-serving lies.
Houston is the most frequently flooded urban area in the country. Officials at the federal, state and local level were repeatedly warned by scientists and weather experts that the license given to real estate developers and speculators to pave over wetlands, as well as the government’s refusal to build proper flood defenses, was setting the city up for an unprecedented flood disaster. These warnings were ignored.
This is the 21st century, not the Dark Ages, and the United States is the richest country in the world. Four hundred years ago, the Dutch figured out how to build cities situated below sea level. The US is, moreover, home to some of the most advanced research and engineering institutes in the world. Yet supposedly no one could have anticipated or planned for the flooding of a major city on the Gulf of Mexico?
What has been done in the 12 years since Katrina to prevent more hurricane disasters? Nothing! Or, more accurately, less than nothing, because Katrina was seized on as an opportunity to treat New Orleans as virgin territory for the privatization of public assets and establishment of a free market paradise for big business, to be replicated across the country. The most overt example of this plundering operation was the dismantling of the public school system in favor of private, for-profit charter schools.
Catastrophes such as the Texas flood are social crimes, committed by a financial aristocracy that has spent the past half-century plundering the country and neglecting its social infrastructure, while accumulating unimaginable sums of personal wealth. According to the corporate-controlled media and the entire political establishment—Democrats no less than Republicans—there is no money to build up flood defenses or rebuild crumbling bridges, roads and water systems, modernize and expand public transport or provide decent schools and housing for the population.
But there are trillions of dollars
stashed away in the bank accounts and
stock portfolios of the rich and the
super-rich. Hundreds of billions are
squandered every year on the
instruments of war.
The country staggers from one preventable disaster to another: Katrina in 2005, the BP oil spill in 2010, Superstorm Sandy in 2012, and now Harvey. In between are countless floods, tornadoes, fires and other events that wreak havoc on working class and poor families, who are left to fend for themselves by a ruling elite drowning in its own excess.
Just as in the feudal era, when the development of society required the expropriation of the landed aristocracy, so today society must seize control of its own resources from the modern aristocracy of finance and corporate wealth. The barbarians of today, who hoard society’s wealth and say nothing can be done to address poverty, disease, war or repression, must go the way of all ruling classes that stand in the way of social progress.
It is not that society cannot afford the type of social investment needed to prevent or minimize the impact of events such as Hurricane Harvey. What society cannot afford is the rich.
It is to the working class—united across all racial, national and ethnic lines, both in the US and internationally—that the task falls of removing this monstrous obstacle to progress from the historical scene. The capitalist parasites must be expropriated, their wealth used to meet social needs, and their stranglehold over the means of production shattered to allow the rational, planned and humane development of economic and social life on the basis of socialist ownership and democratic control of industry, finance and the planet’s natural resources.
Barry Grey
BLOG: HOW MANY BILLIONS HAVE PUMPED INTO MUSLIM DICTATORSHIPS?
Government negligence
exacerbates Hurricane Harvey damage in Houston, Texas
By
Charles Abelard in Houston and Jerry White
29 August 2017
The residents of Houston, Texas are battling record rainfall and
rising floodwaters from Hurricane Harvey, now a tropical storm. The region is
bracing for a second landfall, expected on Wednesday morning.
The storm is responsible for at least nine deaths and billions of
dollars in damage in Houston, the nation’s fourth largest city. Houston and
other areas in Texas are already drowning under 30 to 40 inches of rain. Up to
20 inches of new rainfall is expected by Thursday, and the storm is set to
break rainfall and flooding records by substantial amounts.
The emergency shelters hastily established by authorities in
Houston are overflowing with at least 30,000 residents. The number of
fatalities and injuries will likely increase over the next few days, as fast-moving
water, fouled with sewage, chemicals and debris, prevents rescuers from
reaching flooded areas and helping residents, particularly the poor, sick and
elderly, escape to safety.
Even after the tropical storm system moves to the east, the city’s
rivers, creeks and bayous will continue to flood into Houston’s neighborhoods
for weeks to come. Waterways are not expected to crest for another three to
four days.
Seeking to avoid the political disaster President George W. Bush
suffered during Hurricane Katrina, President Donald Trump is traveling to the
region today. In a press conference Monday, he made perfunctory remarks about
the flooding and assured residents that there would be adequate federal funding
to rebuild the city.
Trump dodged questions about the impact of his proposed cuts to
the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) on rescue efforts, as well as
questions about his threat to shut down the federal government if Congress does
not provide funding for his proposed wall along the Mexican border.
A little more than a week before Hurricane Harvey hit Texas, Trump
signed an executive order revoking a set of regulations to make
federally-funded infrastructure projects less vulnerable to flooding and sea
level rises due climate change. As the hurricane bore down on Houston—the home
of the largest number of undocumented immigrants in the country.
The San Jacinto River, which divides Harris and Montgomery
counties, is flowing over its banks and creating serious flooding in northern
suburbs. Two reservoirs, the Addicks and Barker, which are normally dry and
used for pastureland, are so full that officials from the Army Corps of
Engineers ordered a controlled release of water to ease pressure on dams and
prevent a breach.
The release of water into the Buffalo Bayou will caused flooding
in neighborhoods along its banks. While multi-million-dollar homes in the
affluent community of Memorial are protected by 30 to 40 foot riverbanks, the
working class neighborhoods in the flat and low-lying areas, east of the
downtown area and along the industrialized Houston Shipping Channel, are
expected to suffer increased flood damage.
The chief victims of the flooding are the poor and working class.
One pregnant woman, who works two jobs, told Click2Houston.com that she had
lost a car she had just bought and that her apartment had been flooded. Houston
is the home of 100,000 refugees from Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans.
While wide swaths of the city are working class and poor, only New
York City is home to more Fortune 500 corporations than Houston. Houston’s
corporate giants include ConocoPhillips, Halliburton, Marathon Oil and other
energy and oil industry conglomerates. The city was formerly the headquarters
of Enron.
Former president George H.W. Bush and his wife issued a statement
saluting the “flotilla of volunteers—Points of Light all—who are answering the
call to help their neighbors” and the “local elected officials for their grit
and determination in the face of this extraordinary storm.”
In contrast to the corporate-controlled politicians, working class
residents of all races and nationalities have demonstrated enormous
self-sacrifice and social solidarity. They have used fishing boats, inflated
rafts and even inflated mattresses to rescue neighbors and strangers.
Although the city is prone to flooding, and recently passed
through damaging floods during the “Tax Day Flood” on April 15, 2016 and the
“Memorial Day Flood” in 2015, the official response has been haphazard and
chaotic.
And while there were advance warnings of the approaching storm,
Mayor Sylvester Turner, a Democrat, did not issue a mandatory evacuation order,
citing the dangers of a hurried, “unplanned” evacuation. This was a reference
to the disaster following Hurricane Rita in 2005, when area freeways quickly
clogged and thousands were trapped in their cars for 18 hours or more.
Commuters ran out of gas and water and many elderly evacuees perished.
The previous disaster produced by an unplanned evacuation has been
used by local officials to justify no evacuation at all, leaving tens of
thousands at the mercy of unprecedented flooding.
THE BIG “DEAL MAKER” TWITTER TRUMP WORKS OUT A NO WALL DEAL WITH NARCOMEX
….. LA RAZA WILL NOT BE PAYING FOR THE ALL THAT MIGHT IMPEDED THEIR SUCKING OF $100 BILLION PER YEAR OUT OF AMERICA’S OPEN AND UNDEFENDED BORDERS!
WHILE THE SWAMP KEEPER TWITTER TRUMPER SERVES THE SUPER RICH…. The wall remains a joke on Legals and HUNDREDS OF STORES across America’s OPEN BORDERS are being shuttered by the hundreds!
WALL STREET TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE: DIE YOUNG… your company pension dies with you!
OPOID AND ALCOHOL ADDICTION KILLS OF MIDDLE AMERICA
SOARING POVERTY AND DRUG ADDICTION UNDER OBAMA
"These figures present a scathing indictment of the social order that prevails in America, the world’s wealthiest country, whose government proclaims itself to be the globe’s leading democracy. They are just one manifestation of the human toll taken by the vast and all-pervasive inequality and mass poverty
AMERICA UNRAVELS:
Millions of children go hungry as the super- rich gorge themselves and ILLEGALS SUCK IN BILLIONS IN WELFARE!
"The top 10 percent of Americans now own roughly three-quarters of all household wealth."
http://mexicanoccupation.blogspot.com/2017/08/america-unravels-millions-of-children.html
"While telling workers there is “not enough money” for wage increases, or to fund social programs, both parties hailed the recent construction of the U.S.S. Gerald Ford, a massive aircraft carrier that cost $13 billion to build, stuffing the pockets of numerous contractors and war profiteers."
JAMES WALSH
THE OBAMA HISPANICAZATION of AMERICA
How the Democrat party surrendered America to Mexico:
“The watchdogs at Judicial Watch discovered documents that reveal how the Obama administration's close coordination with the Mexican government entices Mexicans to hop over the fence and on to the American dole.” Washington Times
SOARING POVERTY AND DRUG ADDICTION UNDER OBAMA
SOARING POVERTY AND DRUG ADDICTION UNDER OBAMA
"These figures present a scathing indictment of the social order that prevails in America, the world’s wealthiest country, whose government proclaims itself to be the globe’s leading democracy. They are just one manifestation of the human toll taken by the vast and all-pervasive inequality and mass poverty.
MEXICO: AMERICA’S DRUG DEALER!
The same period has seen a massive growth of social inequality, with income and wealth concentrated at the very top of American society to an extent not seen since the 1920s.
“This study follows reports released over the past several months documenting rising mortality rates among US workers due to drug addiction and suicide, high rates of infant mortality, an overall leveling off of life expectancy, and a growing gap between the life expectancy of the bottom rung of income earners compared to those at the top.”
THE LA RAZA PLAN: California’s final
surrender to fly the Mexican flag within 4 years.
surrender to fly the Mexican flag within 4 years.
"The American Southwest seems to be slowly returning to the jurisdiction of Mexico without firing a single shot." -- - EXCELSIOR --- national newspaper of Mexico
They claim all of North America for Mexico!
(WARNING! THE BELOW LINK IS GRAPHIC ON MEXICAN HATRED OF LEGALS)
THE LIFE OF HILLARY CLINTON:
AMORAL PSYCHOPATH and GLOBAL LOOTER OF THE POOR….. But she served Obama’s crony bank$ter$ well!
AMORAL PSYCHOPATH and GLOBAL LOOTER OF THE POOR….. But she served Obama’s crony bank$ter$ well!
August 27, 2017
Is Medicaid fuelling the opioid crisis?
Without thinking much about it, someone who overdoses on prescription opioids of heroin can just keep going right back to Medicaid for more easy access to the drug that nearly killed them the first time. The state just keeps paying for it.
Which is why, according to a new study, Medicaid recipients are three times more likely to overdose on opioids than people on private insurance.
Sure, it's easy to dismiss the opioid crisis as a phenomenon peculiar to people at the bottom of the socioeconomic ladder. But obviously, there are causes and mechanisms here, which is why the numbers are coming in as they are. It's not just the supposed character flaws of those taking these opioids that is at work, it's the drug dealer that accommodates them on the other side, which in this case, the state. Dependency on the state seems to be fuelling dependency on drugs as much as anything.
According to the Washington Free Beacon:
The study evaluated Medicaid claims in Pennsylvania from 2008 through 2013 for those individuals ages 12 to 64 who had experienced a prescription opioid or heroin overdose. There were 6,013 cases found—3,945 were individuals who overdosed on prescription opioids and 2,068 overdosed on heroin.According to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, individuals on Medicaid are three times more likely to have a risk of opioid overdose than those who are privately insured.Fifty-nine percent of those who overdosed on opioids were given opioid prescriptions after they overdosed, and 39.7 percent of those who overdosed on heroin were given the same."Our findings signal a relatively weak health system response to a potentially life-threatening event," said Julie Donahue, Ph.D., who authored the study. "However, they also point to opportunities for interventions that could prevent future overdoses in a particularly vulnerable population."
Notice also that the states that have increased Medicaid expansion in the greatest amounts due to the Affordable Care Act are also the ones that are known to have the greatest problems with the opioid crisis, if one takes a look at this graph here:
This is not to say there aren't other causes for the opioid crisis as well. President Obama's open borders policy opened the floodgates for cartel imports of opiates for one. The pressures on the medical profession, in which doctors are pressed by addicts to prescribe opioids in unsafe amounts or else be hit with bad patient reviews is another. There also is the poverty and lack of opportunity that motivates many to want to take opioids. But there is little doubt the round-heeled way Medicaid prescribes in its runaway expense culture plays a role, too.
So much for the claim about the heartlessness of private insurance companies. At least its recipients are alive to tell about it. Things happen because there are incentives for them to happen. If a gift is freely given, you take it, as Milton Friedman once observed. And to paraphrase his student, Thomas Sowell, you can have all the opioid addiction you'd like to pay for.
MEXICO: AMERICA’S DRUG DEALER!
The same period has seen a massive growth of social inequality, with income and wealth concentrated at the very top of American society to an extent not seen since the 1920s.
“This study follows reports released over the past several months documenting rising mortality rates among US workers due to drug addiction and suicide, high rates of infant mortality, an overall leveling off of life expectancy, and a growing gap between the life expectancy of the bottom
rung of income earners compared to those at the top.”
The Heroes Of Houston Are The Perfect Cure For What Ails The United States
There’s nothing like a crisis, whether borne by nature or made by man, to unite the human spirit.
We’ve seen it play out numerous times before, whether it was in the days after 9/11, when neighbor comforted neighbor and the nation stood as one against terror, or that day back in June of 2015, when residents of Charleston joined hands by the thousands to march across Arthur Ravenel Bridge in a show of unity following the murders at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church.
And now we’re seeing images of
that same spirit being splashed
across our TV screens and
covering our social media
pages as the heroes of Houston
emerge to help one another cope
with the devastating effects of
Hurricane Harvey.
Authorities in Houston estimate they’ve conducted 2,000 rescue missions thus far, and that doesn’t take into account the numerous instances of people wading into neck-high waters to help others escape from submerging cars or folks who have launched their boats and scoured neighborhoods for the stranded.
TIME put together a montage of just a few of the rescues taking place across Houston:
And then there’s the “Cajun Navy” that has deployed from southern Louisiana, a ragtag group of boat owners looking to help others as they themselves were helped when Hurricane Katrina ravaged their communities back in 2005, forcing many of them to seek shelter in Houston. And Houston welcomed them with open arms, which is why the Cajuns are now staging their own Dunkirk-esque rescue mission.
It’s times like these when real America gets to show who they are and what they are made of — usually in stark contrast to how they are portrayed by the media and Hollywood. Let’s face it, the media and the coastal elites love to put Americans in boxes based on race, religion, political leanings, or any number of descriptors that don’t come close to describing the fabric of our society. It’s easier to write us off that way.
But we are so much bigger and better than those puny little boxes can contain and those puny little minds can imagine. Here’s the “secret” the media doesn’t want you to know: this is how it is most of the time in communities across the country, whether it’s a block party to celebrate friendships, or a community coming together to find a lost dog, or a GoFundMe account to help a young family pay unexpected medical costs.
We’re always one hurricane or terrorist attack or lost dog or sick child away from seeing the true grit of Americans, which is to say that it is always on display. And it’s not the small numbers of white supremacists rallying to save a Robert E. Lee statue or even the larger number of antifa fascists whose Cat 5 hatefulness for the U.S. is wreaking havoc on cities and monuments nationwide.
No, it’s the Coast Guard frogmen dropping out of helicopters to pluck families (and, often, their cherished pets) out of danger; it’s the lady going for a walk who happens upon a stranger being swept away in floodwaters who ignores the danger to herself to help a fellow human; it’s the reporter who comes across a truck driver stuck in his cab (that is dangerously close to being filled with water) doing the right thing and flagging down help.
But you wouldn’t know that this is real America, judging by CNN’s endless Trump bashing or The New York Times continually ignoring the true peril of the antifa crowd. If there is a silver lining in what’s going on right now in Houston (and, yes, it’s surely of little comfort to those who’ve lost their homes and possessions), it’s that social media is bursting at the seams with example after example of the best that Americans have to offer one another. And our best is pretty damn awesome.
Let the white supremacists march. Let the antifa destroy (as long as they keep destroying liberal havens like Berkeley). The heroes of Houston are here, and they are just what we need to remind the media, Hollywood, and coastal elites that America is great because everyday Americans are good.
EYE ON THE NEWS
Houston, Inundated
Geographical luck matters in surviving big storms—but so does government competence. August 28, 2017
Public safety
Even three days after the storm, we know little about how well Houston will survive Hurricane Harvey. As we learned in Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans 12 years ago tomorrow, as well as in Superstorm Sandy in New York five years ago this October, the hardest part of a storm comes after the rain stops. One terrible fact is becoming increasingly clear: despite several major storms in the past two decades, we still don’t know how to get millions of people out of the way of a storm’s path.
Why didn’t Houston evacuate? Twelve years ago, it’s worth recalling, New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin ordered city residents to leave the day before the Category 3 Katrina hit. Of the city’s roughly half-million residents, about 100,000 didn’t comply; of the people who stayed behind, 682 died, comprising the majority of the 917 victims in Louisiana. Yet late last week in Houston, as the Category 4 storm neared its Friday night landfall with windspeeds of up to 130 miles per hour, city and county officials told residents to hunker down.
This may sound like a failure, but New Orleans—where rescue operations were often botched—and Houston are very different cities. Much of New Orleans lies under sea level. The Mississippi River and Lake Pontchartrain, which border the city, often sit above it, kept out by levees and flood walls. The big risk Katrina posed (which eventually became reality) was that these levees and walls would break, trapping tens of thousands of people in their homes in the city’s lowest-lying areas.
The risk that Harvey posed to Houston—and that Sandy posed to New York and New Jersey—was different. Water has risen more gradually—and continues to rise—from rain, not from a large body of water suddenly bursting its walls. The death toll from Harvey will surely rise from single digits, but it will almost certainly stay lower than the thousands who would have died in New Orleans had they not left town before Katrina.
Other differences are logistical. New Orleans is a small city within driving distance of a much bigger one (Houston). But as Judge Ed Emmett, an elected official who shares responsibility over Houston, said today, “if we had gone out three days before and said, we want four million people to leave Harris County, that would have been a totally nonsensical thing to do.” Houston already is the biggest metropolitan center within any realistic driving distance, so an evacuation would have merely overwhelmed the roads and resources of the surrounding area. Mass evacuation is dangerous in itself, as Houston learned just weeks after Katrina, when dozens of people died in car crashes fleeing Hurricane Rita, including 23 on a bus that caught fire, or from heatstroke, or, in the case of the elderly and sick, from the trauma of escaping.
Mandatory evacuations also invariably leave people behind. New Orleans residents’ failure to evacuate fully ahead of Katrina was no more an extreme case than what New York experienced before Sandy. Despite government calls for 375,000 people in Battery Park City and along coastal areas to leave before Sandy, at least half stayed, and 43 people died. If Houston had issued an evacuation order, hundreds of thousands of people would probably not have heeded it, leaving the city in basically the same situation it’s in today. Three days after the storm, as people flee the waters, Houston is providing safe public shelter for the tens of thousands of people who’ve had to leave, or need rescue from, their homes—something New Orleans couldn’t do.
State and local competence is just as important as geography when it comes to surviving big storms. After Katrina, New Orleans’s woes were exacerbated by the city’s longstanding failures—above all, its inability to police the city competently and keep residents safe from street crime. New Orleans’s post-Katrina dangers were exaggerated, in part by the mayor, but they were real. Women were raped in communal shelters. Looters distracted rescue workers.
People who had never trusted the police or their fellow pedestrians on a good day, and who had lived with “constant gunfire” before Katrina, were understandably even more terrified when the lights went out and the storm-struck city was mostly empty. In New York post-Sandy, by contrast, even the parts of the city that suffered from power outages stayed safe. A city that can protect its citizenry during the good times may face bigger challenges during the bad, but it will have the necessary foundation to maintain order.
Before Harvey hit, Houston had a murder rate of about 13 per 100,000 residents. That’s nowhere near as low as New York, with its own murder rate at fewer than four equivalent homicides, but it’s much better than New Orleans, with its homicide rate in 2004, the year before Katrina, of 59 murders per 100,000 people (and 45 today). Houston has also seen its population soar, from 1.6 million in 1980 to 2.3 million today. New Orleans, before Katrina, was shrinking, from 558,000 in 1980 to 455,000 in 2005: thriving municipalities have more civic unity and the necessary service infrastructure to respond to crisis than do cities in decline.
Rescue and recovery from a big storm is hard no matter where you live. New York stumbled after Sandy, coming too slowly to the aid of people trapped in housing projects with no power. But a city that’s doing well before a disaster is better equipped to deal with a disaster when it comes. Crises don’t change a city’s capabilities. Rather, as both Katrina and Sandy demonstrated, they reveal and magnify them.
Thank you, heroes of Houston, for all you are doing!
rung of income earners compared to those at the top.”
No comments:
Post a Comment