Behind the epidemic of police killings in America: Class, poverty and race
Part two
Income and poverty
According to the US Census Bureau, 328 million people reside in the United States. Non-Hispanic whites make up 60.7 percent, black or African American 13.4 percent, and Hispanics or Latino 18.1 percent of the population. The annual median household income (MHI) in 2016 dollars amounts to $55,322 and the percentage of the population living in poverty stands at 12.3 percent. There is wide variation in these figures from state to state. Table 2 below highlights these facts. The table also demonstrates a broadly uniform phenomenon: the areas in which police killings occurred—either the cities and towns, or in the case of rural districts, the counties—almost always have lower median household incomes and more people living in poverty than the statewide average.
In 2017, according to the Washington Post, 987 people were shot and killed by the police. Overwhelmingly, men constituted 95.2 percent of those killed. Racial demographics included 475 white non-Hispanic victims (48.2 percent), 231 black victims (23.4 percent) and 209 Hispanic victims (21.2 percent). Twenty-five Native Americans made up 2.5 percent of those killed though they constitute only 1.3 percent of the population. On the other hand, 19 Asians represented 1.9 percent of those killed though they constitute 5.8 percent of the US population.
Twenty-six people (after the data was cross-referenced with KilledbyPolice.net and news sources) had an unknown race assigned. They made up 2.6 percent of those killed by police.
When this data is standardized to the number killed per 100,000, whites were killed at 0.237 per 100k, blacks at 0.530 per 100k and Hispanics at 0.358 per 100k. The ratio of black death rate to white death rate stands at 2.24 and the ratio of Hispanic death rate to whites death rate at 1.51. This data is consistent with the published literature and often quoted to support the racialist perspective.
The police killing zone: USA−
However, when we calculated the demographics only for the regions in which a police killing occurred, there was a significant shift in both the demographics and socioeconomic status of this new population. We used the suffix minus (−) to denote the narrower region where a killing occurred. Illinois− would mean only those cities and rural counties in Illinois where police killed civilians. USA− includes only the cities and rural counties throughout the country in which a police killing occurred.
The region designated USA− accounts for 91,526,100 people. In other words, slightly more than one-quarter of the US population lives in a city or county where a police killing took place, and conversely, just under three-quarters live in cities or counties that were free of such killings.
The population of USA− has significantly different demographics from the USA as a whole. Non-Hispanic whites made up 44.5 percent, blacks 18.6 percent and Hispanics 26.7 percent of this region. The median household income is slightly lower at $52,218 per annum, and the percentage in poverty (PP) is much higher, at 19.5 percent.
If one compares the poverty rate of USA− to the poverty rate of the remaining nearly three-quarters of the country, where no police killings took place, the disparity is even more stark. The poverty rate is 19.5 percent in what might be called the police killing zone. It is only 9.5 percent, less than half that rate, in the rest of the country.
While poverty becomes a much more salient factor when considering just USA−, the opposite is true for race. In USA−, non-Hispanic whites experienced 1.169 deaths per 100,000, blacks 1.357 per 100,000 and Hispanics 0.856 per 100,000. The ratio of the black death rate to the white death rate was cut nearly in half, to 1.16, and the Hispanic to white ratio declined by more than half, to 0.73. Though blacks continued to be killed at a higher rate than whites, the differences between them became less profound. Comparing observed to expected, based upon the population living in USA−, 38 more whites (8.6 percent) were killed than expected, 47 more blacks (25.6 percent) were killed than expected but 67 fewer Hispanics (25.5 percent) were killed than expected.
When looking at economic data by race, in USA−, regions where white non-Hispanics were killed, the mean household income was $46,720 and 17.6 percent of the population was living in poverty, for blacks the figures were $47,010 and 20.3 percent, and for Hispanics, $50,070 and 19.1 percent.
Urban and rural differences
Only eighty-two black individuals (35.5 percent of all blacks killed by police) died in rural areas with populations of less than 100,000, excluding suburbs. These represented 8.3 percent of all people killed by police in 2017. The median household income in these regions is $41,661, and the proportion living in poverty stands at 20.9 percent.
Forty-five percent of all blacks killed by police were killed in large urban areas with populations of more than 300,000 (including the suburbs) while 20 percent were killed in smaller urban centers between 100,000 and 300,000, for a combined total of 65 percent of all blacks being killed in urban centers. The median household income and proportion in poverty in the urban centers where blacks were killed were $48,088 and 20.8 percent, respectively. Only seventeen black people were killed in suburbs (7.4 percent of all blacks and 1.7 percent of all people killed by police) where the median household income and proportion in poverty stand at $67,178 and 10.5 percent, respectively.
In contrast, out of 478 whites killed by police, 292 (61.7 percent of all whites killed and 29.6 percent of the people killed by police) were killed in rural areas with less than 100,000 population. The median household income and proportion living in poverty were $42,213 and 18.0 percent, respectively.
This figure is worth pondering. The number of whites killed by police in rural areas, 292, is just about exactly twice the number of blacks killed by police in urban areas, 149. But these white victims of police violence are almost invisible when it comes to reporting in the corporate-controlled media, speeches by Democratic Party politicians, or commentary by the pseudo-left groups. Moreover, the income and poverty rates in the two areas are comparable: both white and black victims of police violence live in lower-income working-class areas characterized by much higher than average poverty rates.
There were 124 (25.9 percent of whites killed) in population centers (excluding suburbs) with more than 100,000. Of these, 66 whites (13.8 percent of whites killed by police and 6.7 percent of all victims) died in large urban centers with more than 300,000 population. The median household income and proportion in poverty were $48,675 and 18.5 percent, respectively. Sixty white people were killed in suburbs, accounting for 12.5 percent of whites killed. These regions have a median household income and proportion in poverty of $69,082 and 8.0 percent, respectively.
The demographics of Hispanics killed by police were closer to those of blacks than whites, in that more were killed in larger urban centers. Rural areas accounted for 40.9 percent of Hispanics killed by police (8.6 percent of all victims) while 59.1 percent of Hispanics (12.5 percent of all victims) were killed in urban centers, including the suburbs and metro areas.
The most dangerous area: rural America
Metropolitan centers denote urban centers with more than one million people. There were ten such centers in which 76 people were killed. This region contributed 28.4 percent of USA− but accounted for only 7.7 percent of those killed. Blacks and Hispanics accounted for 35.5 percent each to those killed while whites were only 27.2 percent. Blacks were over-represented in metropolitan centers, at almost twice their proportion in the population.
Large cities included urban centers between 300,000 to one million people. There were 152 people killed in 46 cities and large suburbs. This region accounted for 27.4 percent of USA− but contributed to 15.4 percent of those killed. Blacks again were over-represented in these regions at nearly twice the expected rate, comprising 40.1 percent of those killed.
Population centers with more than 100,000 people but less than 300,000 included many small cities and exurbs. In these regions, 171 people were killed. Combined, they contributed 22.7 percent of USA- and contributed to 17.3 percent of those killed. The rate of whites killed rose while that for blacks declined to a level more consistent with their population in these regions though blacks continued to be over-represented.
Together these urban centers accounted for 399 killed, making up 40.4 percent of those killed by police in 2017. These areas, however, represented 78.5 percent of the population in USA−, the combined regions where police killings occurred. By contrast, the rural regions, which encompassed 463 small and medium towns, including counties with less than 100,000 people, accounted for only 16.8 percent of USA−. However, they accounted for 50.2 percent of the people killed by police, a remarkable 496 victims.
By comparison to urban centers where death rates are on the order of magnitude less than one killed per 100,000 people, medium-sized cities had a rate for whites of 1.946, blacks 3.564 and Hispanics of 2.259. In small towns and rural areas, these rates climbed to a staggering 12.016 per 100,000 for whites, 15.703 for blacks and 11.755 for Hispanics.
2018 begins with US police
reign of terror
29 January 2018
Police kill over a thousand
for fourth year in a row
By George Gallanis
Court quashes subpoena of
reporter who uncovered Chicago police murder coverup
By George
Marlowe
2018 begins with US police
reign of terror
29 January 2018
While largely ignored by the mass media, the reign of terror by
police officers continues to rage across the United States. The entire state
apparatus, from local cops to immigration agents, has been unleashed by the
Trump administration to beat, maim and kill with impunity.
During a speech to hundreds of uniformed officers last July, Trump
urged the police to not be “too nice” and to treat detainees “rough.” The
Justice Department has at the same time ended the toothless pretense of federal
oversight over a handful of police departments put in place by the Obama
administration.
In the year since Trump was sworn in as president, at least 1,223
people have been killed by police. Since the beginning of 2018, according to
killedbypolice.net, 3.5 people have been killed on average every day.
A Washington Post database
reports 78 fatal police shootings so far this year. As in previous years, the
figures show that police killings impact every race and ethnicity, with whites
comprising the largest share of victims, while African Americans are killed at
a rate higher than their overall percentage of the population. In those cases
where race or ethnicity has been identified by the Post,
54 percent of victims were white, 25 percent African American, 15 percent
Hispanic, 3 percent Asian and 2 percent Native American.
Among the most recent victims is Donte Shannon, a 26-year-old
African American man who was killed by police in Racine, Wisconsin on January
17 after fleeing a traffic stop. According to the police account, Shannon’s
initial crime was not having a front license plate on his vehicle. Officials
claim the police were forced to unleash a hail of bullets after Shannon pointed
a gun at them, though investigators have not reported finding a weapon at the
scene.
On the same day, a deputy in Columbus, Ohio shot and killed
16-year-old Joseph Haynes, a white youth, during an altercation after a court
hearing. Haynes, who was unarmed, was thrown to the ground and shot once in the
abdomen after he confronted a deputy for pushing his mother up against a wall.
In addition to those killed, workers and youth are subjected to
police harassment and brutality on a daily basis.
Earlier this month, Louisiana teacher Deyshia Hargrave was removed
from a school board meeting and handcuffed by a deputy marshal after she raised
questions about school officials awarding themselves raises while denying them
to teachers and staff. Former coal miner Gary Michael Hunt was choked by a
police officer and removed from a public meeting after demanding clean water
for the residents of Martin County, Kentucky.
Not even children are spared, as shown by a report Sunday that a
7-year-old child in Miami, Florida was led away from his school in handcuffs
after an altercation with a teacher last week.
The issue of police killings and brutality erupted into national
and international prominence with the murder of Michael Brown in August 2014
and the militarized police response to protests. Popular anger over police
violence has not gone away. However, over the past three and a half years there
has been a systematic effort to smother opposition and channel it behind the
Democratic Party.
A critical role has been played by Black Lives Matter (BLM), which
was developed and promoted to push the false claim that police violence is a
racial rather than a class issue. Along with the various other organizations
that promote and support the Democratic Party, BLM sought to cover up the
relationship between police violence and the nature of the capitalist state as
an instrument of class repression. BLM pushed for various reforms, including
body cameras, oversight boards and more minority police officers, as the
supposed solution to police violence.
In 2016, the main leaders of BLM threw their support behind
Hillary Clinton, the favored candidate of Wall Street and the
military-intelligence apparatus. During the election season, the Ford
Foundation announced that it would funnel $100 million to a panoply of
organizations associated with the BLM movement. This was followed by the
announcement of an initiative by BLM to promote “black capitalism,” including
the introduction of a Black Lives Matter debit card.
The Democratic Party is fully complicit in the epidemic of police
violence. The Obama administration presided over the continued militarization
of police forces while ensuring that nothing was done to prosecute officers who
perpetrated violence.
Since the election of Trump, the Democrats have entirely ignored
the ongoing wave of police killings. They have worked to suppress and divert
all manifestations of social opposition to the Trump administration behind a
reactionary and militarist agenda of aggression against Russia, a further
redistribution of wealth to the rich, and the destruction of democratic rights.
A significant factor in the efforts to censor the Internet,
spearheaded by the Democratic Party, is concern that police killings and abuse
videotaped on smartphones have become national and international issues through
distribution on social media platforms. Facebook is now changing its newsfeed
to limit the reach of content from news sources outside the so-called
“mainstream,” with the aim of preventing the expression and propagation of
opposition to police violence and social inequality.
Opposition to police violence within the United States cannot be
separated from opposition to war, social inequality and the capitalist system.
With wealth concentration rising to levels without historic precedent, the
ruling elite relies on the police to enforce inequality.
And as the Pentagon prepares to wage war abroad on an
unprecedented scale, the ruling class is preparing for war at home. The concept
of “Total Army” has been coined to embrace the innumerable and growing
connections between the police, border patrol, immigration agents and the
military—a single apparatus of war and repression.
The ruling class is well aware that it faces its greatest danger
within the United States, in the form of the growth of working-class struggle
and the development of a mass movement against capitalism. It is only through
the building of such a political movement that the reign of police violence can
be ended.
Niles Niemuth
COP MURDERS IN
AMERICA - THOUSANDS SHOT IN THE HEAD.
JUDGES GIVE THE THUG COPS A PASS TO DO IT AGAIN!
Police kill over a thousand
for fourth year in a row
By George Gallanis
27 December 2017
For the fourth year
in a row, police killed over a thousand people in the United States in one
year. The four-year bloodbath is a stern warning to the working class in America
and across the world. Social inequality is reaching unprecedented levels. Three
billionaires own as much wealth as the bottom half of the population of the
United States. The killings of thousands by police in the span of few years is
an indication of the ruling elite’s fear and hatred of the vast working class
majority.
As of this writing,
killedbypolice.net reports police killed 1,164 people in 2017. With a few days
left in the year, the death count will likely increase, marking 2017 as second
deadliest year since 2013, when the web site began tabulating the figures. Last
year’s count stands at 1,165.
Other police killing aggregators show similar totals. Mapping
Police Violence places the count at 1,049. The Washington Post, which only tracks police
shootings as opposed to other forms of police killings, by means of tasering,
beatings and the like, places the count at 952 as of December 25.
Murder by police is
effectively legal. Police officers can kill anyone, as long as they claim some
kind of perceived threat, whether real or not. Hundreds, many of whom are
unarmed, are murdered by officers who will never face a trial. According to
Mapping Police Violence, in 2015, under the Obama presidency, 99 percent of all
police killings did not result in any police officer being convicted of a crime
by the so-called justice system. The capitalist state shoots and kills with one
hand and washes the blood off with the other.
In November, released
video footage showed an unarmed Daniel Shaver murdered by an Arizona police
officer after begging for his life on his knees. The officer was acquitted of
all charges after claiming he feared for his life. In September, St. Louis
police officer Jason Stockley was acquitted of murder for the 2011 killing of
Anthony Lamar Smith. After shooting Smith six times from close range, Stockley
planted a gun on Smith’s dead body. Stockley’s fingerprints were later found on
the gun.
Following the
verdict, protests erupted in St. Louis. St. Louis police responded, dressed in
riot gear, illegally “kettling” protesters and arresting many all the while
shouting, “Whose streets? Our streets!”
The protests were
largely organized by Black Lives Matters (BLM) and pseudo-left groups such as
the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) and Socialist Alternative, who
sought to portray the killing by Stockley as an act solely due to racism.
Slogans such as “white silence is violence” were heard during the protests.
Three years earlier, in the aftermath of the killing of Michael
Brown by Ferguson, Missouri police officer Darren Wilson, pseudo-left groups
put forth the same narrative: the fundamental cause of police violence is
racism. Often cited to bolster this argument is the fact that blacks are killed
in disproportionately higher numbers compared to whites. According to the Washington Post,
African-Americans comprised a quarter of all police killings in 2017. This
clearly suggests that racism is an element in police killings, but these
statistics only reveal part of the picture. The victims of police killings
include all races and ethnicities. As any good doctor will point out, one must
not confuse a symptom for the disease, and the disease is class oppression,
claiming the poorest and most vulnerable sections of the working class.
The police, along
with the state machine as a whole, exist as an instrument in the irreconcilable
conflict between the ruling class and the working class. The police are not
neutral actors who can be pressured to act in a certain way. They serve the
interests of the capitalist class, and carry out its orders. The thousands that
lay dead at the hands of the police, regardless of skin color and gender, come
almost entirely from the ranks of the working class. Police roam working class
and poor neighborhoods hunting perpetrators of petty crimes. If you are stopped
by the police, you are de facto guilty. If you fidget or do not follow a
command directly, you may very well be shot and die. Whatever part racism plays
in these murders, it is ultimately secondary to that of class.
American society is
divided by massive inequality, intensified by decades of social
counterrevolution. Social tension is palpable, with most working people
increasingly angry and moving to the left. There is deep concern within the
ruling class that social explosions of revolutionary dimensions are on the
horizon. Preparing for such events, police more and more act as an occupying
force, carrying the same weapons used overseas in occupied countries by the
United States. In 1989, Congress passed the National Defense Authorization Act.
It has made possible the transfer of $5.4 billion worth of military gear to
police departments across the United States. A report published by the US
Department of Justice in 2015 states that local police departments swelled to 477,000
full-time personnel in 2013, a 35 percent increase since 1987. This
three-decade period coincides with a drastic decline in crime, while the forces
of “law and order” have been swelled and armed to the teeth.
History demonstrates
the real role of the police. In 1937, for example, Chicago police shot and
killed 10 striking workers during the Little Steel Strike. During the Detroit
Rebellion of 1967, police were given order to ‘shoot to kill,’ claiming 16
victims. In some of the other social explosions of the mid- and late 1960s, the
death toll at the hands of the police was even greater.
Under the Trump
presidency, the police will operate more openly and ruthlessly. Police violence
will grow, accompanied by increased attacks on democratic rights. Social and
political opposition will be met with brutal violence, directed not only
against individuals but also mass struggles.
The efforts of the
proponents of identity politics to place the blame of police violence on racism
effectively denies the role of the state and its class character. This serves
to create divisions within the working class along ethnic and racial lines. It
leads to the counterproductive and reactionary conclusion that the police can
be reformed by increasing the number of minority officers, or through such
techniques as community policing, racial-sensitivity training and similar
nostrums.
Court quashes subpoena of
reporter who uncovered Chicago police murder coverup
By George
Marlowe
27 December 2017
On December 13, a Cook County judge quashed an anti-press subpoena
against independent journalist Jamie Kalven that would have forced him to
disclose his confidential sources in court. Kalven was the first to bring to
light the coverup of the police murder of 17-year-old Laquan McDonald in 2014
by Chicago police officer Jason Van Dyke, who faces charges of first-degree
murder.
Were it not for Kalven, who works with the independent news
organization Invisible Institute, there would have been no exposure of the
police murder of McDonald and the subsequent coverup by the Chicago Police
Department (CPD), the Democratic mayor Rahm Emanuel and the entire political
establishment.
Kalven wrote an explosive article
in Slate in
2015 entitled “Sixteen Shots” that shattered the
official fake news and coverup—promoted by the CPD, the Emanuel administration
and the media. In the article, Kalven revealed that McDonald had been shot
sixteen times across his entire body, according to the autopsy report he had
obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request.
He also cited an unnamed witness who contradicted the entire
official police narrative, which claimed that the teenager was lunging at a
police officer with a knife while under the influence drugs. The witness stated
instead that McDonald was “shying away” from the police officer when he was
shot multiple times. Finally, Kalven revealed that there was a police
dashboard-camera video documenting the entire incident, which he learned from
an unnamed source.
The subpoena—issued by Van Dyke’s lawyers in an attempt to delay
his trial—threatened to undermine basic democratic rights afforded to reporters
under the First Amendment of the US Constitution. Such rights include a
reporter’s constitutional privilege to be protected from being compelled to
testify about confidential information or sources, critical to reporting freely
on matters of public interest. At the same time, attacks on the press have
steadily increased over the last few decades by multiple administrations,
Democratic and Republican.
Van Dyke’s lead attorney, Daniel Herbert, himself a former police
officer, issued the subpoena against Kalven claiming that his reporting
influenced witnesses—thereby tainting the investigation. Kalven’s lawyers
countered that the witnesses in question had already spoken to law enforcement
prior to Kalven’s discussions with them. In reality, the spurious subpoena
issued by Herbert is part of a counter-offensive to intimidate and threaten
reporters who uncover crimes committed by police officers or other agents of
the state.
In demanding the subpoena, Herbert also accused Kalven of being an
activist, rather than a neutral reporter of the facts. He argued therefore that
Kalven could not make use of his reporter’s privilege to maintain the
confidentiality of his sources. While Kalven certainly has taken a point of
view in his reporting on police brutality for many years, and has been a
partisan for the voices of the poor in Chicago’s south side, he is also a
conscientious and objective reporter.
Kalven’s lawyer highlighted the spuriousness of the assault on his
rights. Compelling Kalven to testify about his sources, they noted, violated
the Illinois Reporter’s Privilege Act—which forbids courts from forcing
reporters to disclose the source of information they have obtained
(confidential or not), except where no other law can prevent its disclosure,
and all other sources of information have been exhausted.
An amicus curiae brief
filed by the Reporters Committee for the Freedom of the Press (RCFP) and
eighteen other media organizations noted, “When a subpoena demands information
about confidential sources, the specter of enforcing that subpoena has a
chilling effect on all future sources who may have valuable information about
matters of public concern, but need an assurance of confidentiality before
sharing it.”
In light of the spuriousness of the charges made by Herbert, Judge
Vincent Gaughan was forced to quash the subpoena. Gaughan, however, maintained
he did so not because of Kalven’s protected status as a reporter, but because
of the inadequacy of the subpoena itself. While the dismissal of the subpoena
was a victory for Kalven’s rights as a reporter, the courts have only
maintained a qualified and limited assertion of a reporter’s privilege.
After months of legal and court battles, the Emanuel
administration released the video of the shooting on a late night in 2014. The
video confirmed what the witnesses and autopsy reports showed. Laquan McDonald,
an impoverished ward of the state, unknown to the public until his untimely
death, was shot sixteen times by Van Dyke as he walked away from the officer.
The first few shots took the teenager down. Van Dyke subsequently shot him
multiple times as smoke emerged from his shaking, dying body.
The video of McDonald finally released in November 2015 engulfed
the Emanuel administration in a full-blown political crisis. Protests ensued
nightly and there were widespread calls for Emanuel to resign for his role in
the cover-up. Instead, the Democratic Party and the political establishment
thereafter began a process of damage control.
Emanuel, who bears chief responsibility for the murder, remains in
office and no high-level political figure has been charged. In December of
2015, Emanuel called for the resignation of Superintendent Garry McCarthy, the
head of the CPD at the time of McDonald’s death. Van Dyke was then indicted on
six counts of first-degree murder and one count of official misconduct.
Multiple officers on the scene were involved in a conspiracy to cover up what
happened. The official organs of police oversight, such as the Independent
Police Review Authority, sanctioned the false statements of the officers.
The mainstream press, for their part, uncritically reported what
CPD officials told them, which was that McDonald had lunged at the officer with
a knife. Kalven’s reporting, however, was instrumental in bringing to light the
real circumstances of the murder of McDonald and added to the growing public
outrage against police brutality.
In the wake of the release of the
video, Emanuel also vowed to create a task force for police accountability, in
order to cover up his own tracks. Emails released by the Chicago Tribune later
revealed the entire administration in City Hall was aware of the video and
chose to suppress it. The Justice Department also opened an investigation,
which released its report earlier this year. The report revealed a damning pattern of constitutional abuses by
the CPD. It detailed a history of police brutality and violence in Chicago, but
it only offered mere palliatives and half-measures.
Despite the reporting by Kalven and widespread outrage against
police brutality in Chicago, there has been no fundamental change in the course
of the CPD and its policies. Far from ushering in an era of “police reform”, as
promised by Emanuel in the wake of release of the video footage of the police
murder of McDonald, police violence and brutality continue unabated, in Chicago
and across the country.
THUG RAPIST COPS SELDOM PROSECUTED…. CORRUPT
JUDGES WANT TO MAINTAIN THE STATUSQUO OF JUDGES, THUG COPS AND LAWYERS ARE ALL
ABOVE THE LAW!
According to Killedbypolice.net, at least 808 people have been killed by
police so far this year, outpacing last year’s deaths by 20
victims.... and they ALL GET AWAY WITH IT!
"Police in
the United States are trained to see the working class and poor as a
hostile
enemy. Anything
less than complete submissiveness is grounds for officers to unleash
deadly
force on their victims. In some instances, even the most casual
encounters with
police
have proven to be deadly."
COP MURDERS IN
AMERICA - THOUSANDS SHOT IN THE HEAD.
JUDGES GIVE THE THUG COPS A PASS TO DO IT AGAIN!
No comments:
Post a Comment